Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat
Symbol of the Government of Canada

ARCHIVED - Copyright Board of Canada - Report


Warning This page has been archived.

Archived Content

Information identified as archived on the Web is for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It has not been altered or updated after the date of archiving. Web pages that are archived on the Web are not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards. As per the Communications Policy of the Government of Canada, you can request alternate formats on the "Contact Us" page.

SECTION I: DEPARTMENTAL OVERVIEW

Minister's Message

As Canada's economy shows continued signs of growth following the global recession, the Harper government has a clear vision for Canada. We remain focused on creating jobs and economic growth in all regions of Canada. We remain committed to fighting protectionism, the number one impediment to global economic recovery. And we will continue to support science and technology as it drives innovation to improve quality of life for Canadians.

In the coming year, Industry Canada and its portfolio partners will seize the opportunities of the evolving global economy. We will set the conditions for industrial success by improving the policy we put in place, making strategic investments and supporting business-focused programs and services. We are working to remove impediments to competition and to create the best climate for international investment. Industry Canada will lead efforts in developing major policy initiatives to support Canada's digital economy, and shape a whole-of-government strategy for federal tourism activities. The Department will also improve the cost-effectiveness and efficiency of its own operations and work with recovering industries and sectors to help assure a solid and prosperous future.

In 2011-12, the Copyright Board Canada will continue to ensure balanced decision making and provide proper incentives for the creation and use of copyrighted works. The Board will also examine possible avenues to improve its practices and procedures, with the aim of streamlining them and reducing uncertainty while safeguarding fairness of the process.

And, as always, I will work with the Industry portfolio partners, the private sector and other governments to create the fundamentals for a strong and competitive economy.

As a country, we are emerging from the recession by creating a climate that encourages innovation, productivity and competitiveness — helping Canadian industry move to the forefront of the global knowledge economy. The Industry Portfolio members, and other federal departments and agencies are working in partnership so that Canada continues to enjoy a high standard of living and a prosperous future.

It is my pleasure to present this year's Report on Plans and Priorities for the Copyright Board Canada.

Christian Paradis
Minister of Industry and
Minister of State (Agriculture)

Raison d'être

The Copyright Board of Canada's program objective is to set royalties which are fair and equitable to both copyright owners and users of copyright-protected works. This includes setting fair and equitable terms and conditions so as to permit the use of works when the owner of the copyright cannot be located.

The Board is an independent administrative agency that has been conferred department status for purposes of the Financial Administration Act. The mandate of the Board is set out in the Copyright Act (the "Act"). The Board is empowered to establish, either mandatorily or at the request of an interested party, the royalties to be paid for the use of copyrighted works when the administration of such works is entrusted to a collective administrative society.

The Copyright Board of Canada is an economic regulator. It deals with complex social, cultural, demographic, economic and technological issues. The Board's decisions are not appealable, but can be the subject of judicial review by the Federal Court of Appeal. The Board has existed in one form or another since the 1930s, but its jurisdiction was significantly expanded in 1989 and 1997.

The program objective of the Board underlies the achievement of strategic outcomes related to innovation through new knowledge, which has become the main source of competitive advantage in all sectors of economic activity and is closely associated with increased exports, productivity growth, and the creation of new firms.

In this context, our country's handling of intellectual property matters is a critical element in our long-term success in innovation, and by extension, to our long-term economic health. The terms and conditions by which intellectual property owners (such as owners of copyrighted works) are compensated will largely define the incentive structure for innovation in and creation of copyrighted materials. In addition, the design and implementation of regulations can have a significant impact on innovation and competitiveness, particularly in the areas of intellectual property rights.

Operating Environment

The mandate of the Copyright Board of Canada is set out in the Act as amended in 1997. The Board has powers of a substantive and procedural nature. Some powers are granted to the Board expressly in the Act, and some are implicitly recognized by the courts.

The Act requires that the Board certify tariffs in the following fields: the public performance or communication of musical works and of sound recordings of musical works, the retransmission of distant television and radio signals, the reproduction of television and radio programs by educational institutions and private copying. In other fields where rights are administered collectively, the Board can be asked by a collective society to set a tariff; if not, the Board can act as an arbitrator if the collective society and a user cannot agree on the terms and conditions of a licence.

The examination process is always the same. The collective society must file a statement of proposed royalties which the Board publishes in the Canada Gazette. Tariffs always come into effect on January 1. On or before the preceding 31st of March, the collective society must file a proposed statement of royalties. The users targeted by the proposal (or in the case of private copying, any interested person) or their representatives may object to the statement within sixty days of its publication. The collective society in question and the opponents will then have the opportunity to argue their case in a hearing before the Board. After deliberations, the Board certifies the tariff, publishes it in the Canada Gazette, and explains the reasons for its decision in writing.

As a rule, the Board holds hearings. No hearing will be held if proceeding in writing accommodates a small user that would otherwise incur large costs. The hearing may be dispensed with on certain preliminary or interim issues. No hearings have been held yet for a request to use a work whose owner cannot be located. The process has been kept simple. Information is obtained either in writing or through telephone calls.

Mandate, Roles and Responsibilities


Mandate of the Board
The Board is an economic regulatory body empowered to establish, either mandatorily or at the request of an interested party, the royalties to be paid for the use of copyrighted works, when the administration of such copyright is entrusted to a collective-administration society. The Board also has the right to supervise agreements between users and licensing bodies and issues licences when the copyright owner cannot be located.

The Copyright Board of Canada was established on February 1, 1989, as the successor of the Copyright Appeal Board. Its responsibilities under the Act are to:

  • certify tariffs for the public performance or the communication to the public by telecommunication of musical works and sound recordings [sections 67 to 69];
  • certify tariffs, at the option of a collective society referred to in section 70.1, for the doing of any protected act mentioned in sections 3, 15, 18 and 21 of the Act [sections 70.1 to 70.191];
  • set royalties payable by a user to a collective society, when there is disagreement on the royalties or on the related terms and conditions [sections 70.2 to 70.4];
  • certify tariffs for the retransmission of distant television and radio signals or the reproduction and public performance by educational institutions, of radio or television news or news commentary programs and all other programs, for educational or training purposes [sections 71 to 76];
  • set levies for the private copying of recorded musical works [sections 79 to 88];
  • rule on applications for non-exclusive licences to use published works, fixed performances, published sound recordings and fixed communication signals, when the copyright owner cannot be located [section 77];
  • examine, at the request of the Commissioner of Competition appointed under the Competition Act, agreements made between a collective society and a user which have been filed with the Board, where the Commissioner considers that the agreement is contrary to the public interest [sections 70.5 and 70.6];
  • set compensation, under certain circumstances, for formerly unprotected acts in countries that later join the Berne Convention, the Universal Convention or the Agreement establishing the World Trade Organization [section 78].

In addition, the Minister of Industry can direct the Board to conduct studies with respect to the exercise of its powers [section 66.8].

Finally, any party to a licence agreement with a collective society can file the agreement with the Board within 15 days of its conclusion, thereby avoiding certain provisions of the Competition Act [section 70.5].

Strategic Outcome and Program Activity Architecture (PAA)

Program Activity Architecture
STRATEGIC OUTCOME

Fair decision-making to provide proper incentives for the creation and use of copyrighted works
arrow PROGRAM ACTIVITY

Copyright Tariff Setting and Issuance of Licences

Internal Services

Planning Summary

Financial Resources ($ thousands)

2010-12 2011-13 2012-14
3,125 3,125 3,125

Human Resources (Full-time Equivalents (FTE))

2010-12 2011-13 2012-14
16 16 16

Note: In addition to the 16 full-time equivalents employees, the Board has up to a maximum of 5 Governor-in-Council appointees.


Strategic Outcome: Fair decision-making to provide proper incentives for the creation and use of copyrighted works
Performance Indicator Targets
  1. Percentage of tariff decisions published within 12 months
  2. Percentage of licences issued within 45 days
  3. Level of satisfaction of stakeholders
70% of tariff decisions will be published within one year

70% of licences will be issued within 45 days

70% satisfaction rate
Program Activity Expected Results Forecast Spending 2010-11
($ thousands)
Planned Spending
($ thousands)
Alignment to Government of Canada Outcomes
2010-12 2011-13 2012-14
Copyright Tariff Setting and Issuance of Licences Fair and equitable tariffs and conditions 2,512 2,514 2,514 2,514 An innovative and knowledge-based economy
Internal Services   598 611 611 611
Total Planned Spending   3,110 3,125 3,125 3,125

Innovation through new knowledge has become the main source of competitive advantage in all sectors of economic activity and is closely associated with increased exports, productivity growth, and the creation of new firms. In this context, our country's handling of intellectual property matters is a critical element in our long-term success in innovation, and by extension, to our long-term economic health. The terms and conditions by which intellectual property owners (such as owners of copyrighted works) are compensated will largely define the incentive structure for innovation in and creation of copyrighted materials. In addition, the design and implementation of regulations can have a significant impact on innovation and competitiveness, particularly in the areas of intellectual property rights.

The Copyright Board of Canada recognizes the need to ensure an effective and efficient copyright regulatory regime in order to attain the maximum productivity in those sectors that create and use copyrighted works. Further, the strategic outcomes of a fair and competitive marketplace and reasonable opportunities for Canadian firms to export copyright protected goods and services in the music, content creation and programming areas, as well as the downstream broadcasting, publishing and entertainment industries will be impacted by the performance of the Copyright Board of Canada.

Contribution of Priorities to Strategic Outcome

Departmental Priorities

Priority Name Type Links to Strategic Outcome Description
1. Ensure timely and fair processes and decisions Ongoing Fair decision-making to provide proper incentives for the creation and use of copyrighted works Leads to a more efficient process and to decisions that take into account the ever-changing technological environment, global events and new business models
2. Advance the analytical framework for decisions and the regulatory processes for tariff-setting Ongoing Ensures a proper assessment by the Board of risks associated with economic and technological changes in relevant industries
3. Improve management practices Ongoing Favours the implementation of relevant and efficient management practices at the Board

Operational Priorities

There are three priorities associated with the Copyright Board of Canada's strategic outcome of achieving fair decision-making to provide proper incentives for the creation and uses of copyrighted works. These are:

Ensure timely and fair processes and decisions

To achieve this priority, the Board will need to ensure that participation costs in the hearing process are kept as low as possible, thus encouraging participation of the appropriate parties and streamlining the process. The Board will also need to provide appropriate guidance, information and analysis to the participants in order to facilitate the examination process and to foster greater participants' satisfaction. This will be done in particular through telephone advisories and case management meetings with representatives. Finally, by engaging in pre-hearing consultations and information gathering, and by conducting well organized proceedings which address key issues facing copyright-related industries, the Board will be able to issue timely, fair and consistent decisions.

The monitoring of this priority will be achieved by informally surveying hearing participants, with follow-up examination and determination of alternative procedural practices to improve the efficiency of the regulatory process. The achievement of this result is also directly monitored through the timely conduct of hearing processes and lack of interruption in proceedings due to administrative and technical delays. In addition, the implementation of a pre-hearing joint statement of (non-contested) facts and handling of legal issues solely through written submissions will improve the efficiency of the process. Finally, the Board plans to continue to examine, for each process, how to structure and sequence witnesses and hearing stages so as to eliminate duplication and maximize time spent on relevant issues.

In addition, in 2011-2012 the Board plans to establish a working group comprised of key stakeholders that will examine possible avenues to improve the Board's rules of practice and procedure. These improvements should aim at reducing uncertainty and streamlining the procedures while safeguarding the fairness of the process.

The rationale underlying this priority is to minimize administrative costs to Canadians from the setting of tariffs and to streamline the process in the face of increasing complexities in hearing subject matter, thus increasing regulatory efficiency. To the extent that this also leads to fairer decision-making, the overall innovation capability of parties affected by the copyright tariff process will be improved.

Advance the analytical framework for decisions and the regulatory processes for tariff-setting

Among the most significant risks which the Board faces in achieving its strategic outcomes are the potentially disruptive impact of new technologies, in particular on how copyright material is utilized, distributed and monitored. Fair and equitable decisions critically depend on the Board's ability to identify, understand and assess the industry issues before they undermine or adversely impact existing copyright regimes. The Board's approach to managing the technology risk is to systematically monitor relevant journals, other publications and websites, and to attend industry seminars and conferences.

Knowledge of the international experience is also a key tool in addressing the challenges of changing technology and the impact of global events. By comparing experiences across different countries, the Board expects to gain early warning of significant developments and their likely impacts on the Canadian situation.

Leadership in copyright matters will continue to build on the groundwork performed in the past. The Board plans to continue its leadership role in the establishment and expansion of international activities such as sharing of procedures, data, analysis and other information. With a view to further this leadership, the Board will continue to be actively involved with the international Society for Economic Research on Copyright Issues in 2011-2012.

By its involvement in international activities as they relate to copyright tariff setting in other parts of the world, the Board ensures that its own tariff-setting processes and decisions are cognizant of developments outside of Canada.

Management Priorities

Improve Management Practices

The Board will work toward improving governance and management processes to strengthen organizational capacity and ensure clear accountability for results. In particular, this involves restructuring some of the positions, as well as intensifying our recruitment efforts to fill some of the vacant positions.

The Board is committed to offer training and development to all of its employees, thus encouraging learning and skills development on the part of all employees.

The Board will review its Human Resources Plan to assess the changing needs of the Board and will take into account succession planning. It is essential that the Board has the capacity it needs to better react to the changing nature of work driven by technology, resulting in better service to Canadians.

Furthermore, it will continue to work on an evaluation strategy and performance measurement tools, as well as a legacy storage system for the Board's files.

Risk Analysis

The Board is responsible for tariffs that are estimated to be worth over $300 million annually. In fact, copyright tariffs underpin several industries which, according to a Conference Board of Canada study (Valuing Culture, Measuring and Understanding Canada's Creative Economy, Conference Board of Canada, August 2008), generated in 2007 an amount representing 7.4% of Canada's GDP when taking into account the direct, indirect and induced contribution. They also contributed 1.1 million jobs to the economy. The stakes are considerable for both copyright holders and users. Consequently, interventions before the Board are thorough, sophisticated and often involve expert witnesses, litigation specialists and detailed econometric, business and financial studies, surveys and evidence.

The Board must consider the underlying technologies (such as the Internet, digital radio, satellite communications), the economic issues and the interests of owners and users in order to contribute, with fair and equitable decisions, to the continued growth of this component of Canada's knowledge industries. Sound tariff decisions avoid serious disruption in affected sectors of the national economy and costly and time-consuming court challenges.

The decisions the Board makes are constrained in several respects. These constraints come from sources external to the Board: the law, regulations and judicial pronouncements. Others are self-imposed, in the form of guiding principles that can be found in the Board's decisions.

Court decisions also provide a large part of the framework within which the Board operates. Most decisions focus on issues of procedure, or apply the general principles of administrative decision-making to the specific circumstances of the Board. However, the courts have also set out several substantive principles for the Board to follow or that determine the ambit of the Board's mandate or discretion.

The Board also enjoys a fair amount of discretion, especially in areas of fact or policy. In making decisions, the Board itself has used various principles or concepts. Strictly speaking, these principles are not binding on the Board. They can be challenged by anyone at anytime. Indeed, the Board would illegally fetter its discretion if it considered itself bound by its previous decisions. However, these principles do offer guidance to both the Board and those who appear before it. In fact, they are essential to ensuring a desirable amount of consistency in decision-making.

Among those factors, the following seem to be the most prevalent: the coherence between the various elements of the public performance of music tariffs, the practicality aspects, the ease of administration to avoid tariff structures that make it difficult to administer the tariff in a given market, the search for non-discriminatory practices, the relative use of protected works, the taking into account of Canadian circumstances, the stability in the setting of tariffs that minimizes disruption to users, as well as the comparisons with "proxy" markets and comparisons with similar prices in foreign markets.

Expenditure Profile

For fiscal year 2011-12, the Copyright Board of Canada plans to spend $3.1 million to meet the expected results of its program activities and contribute to its strategic outcome.

The figure below illustrates the Copyright Board of Canada's spending trend from 2007-08 to 2013-14.

Copyright Board's spending trend from 2007-08 to 2013-14

For the 2007-08 to 2010-11 periods, the total spending includes all Parliamentary appropriations: Main Estimates, Supplementary Estimates, Treasury Board Vote 10, 15, and 23. It also includes carry forward adjustments. For the 2011-12 to 2013-14 periods, the total and the planned spending coincide. Supplementary funding and carry forward adjustments are unknown at this point and are therefore not reflected.

The core funding excludes carry forward adjustments and supplementary funding. It illustrates the baseline funding the Copyright Board of Canada receives from Parliamentary appropriations.

Voted and Statutory Items

($ thousands)
Vote or Statutory Item Truncated Vote or Statutory wording 2011-12
Main Estimates
2010-11
Main Estimates
45 Program expenditures 2,815 2,818
(S) Contributions to employee benefit plans 310 293
  Total Department 3,125 3,110

Note: The difference between the 2010-2011 and 2011-2012 Main Estimates is due to salary increases and adjustments to the Employee benefit plans.

Details may not add to totals due to rounding.